Chancellor urged to strike new settlement for self-employed in Budget

12 February 2021

An Inquiry backed by unions and business groups calls for a rebalancing of risk for the self-employed after the pandemic

Chancellor Rishi Sunak has been urged to use his Budget on 3rd March to give greater security to self-employed workers and prevent a possible ‘exodus’ from self-employment in the wake of the Covid pandemic.

Covid-19 has shone a light on the precarious nature of self-employment, and many creative freelancers have fallen through the cracks of government support and been left without assistance for nearly a year. Bectu has been campaigning for a new deal for freelancers and has frequently called upon the Government to address the flaws of the SEISS and create secure provisions for the self-employed.

Head of Bectu, Philippa Childs, gave evidence to the Inquiry regarding the exclusion of freelancers in the Creative sector. Bectu welcomes the Inquiry into the future of self-employment and implores the Chancellor to consider its recommendations.

Findings of the Inquiry

The Inquiry found that a majority of self-employed workers were unsure about continuing to freelance in the future, with a clear appetite for a stronger safety net if they are to continue.

If these workers did decide to give up on their businesses in favour of more secure working conditions, the impact on the recovery from the pandemic could be drastic, the Inquiry warns. To avert this fate, the Chancellor should take action to strengthen the safety net for the self-employed.

The package of recommended policy measures includes:

  • Ending the exclusions from the government’s income support packages
  • Extending health and safety rights at work, sick pay, and paid parental leave to the self employed
  • Changes to Universal Credit and the pensions system so they work for the self employed
  • A new Commissioner for the Self Employed in government to coordinate policy efforts
  • Redrawing definitions of self-employment to be more inclusive, and delaying controversial IR35 rules which will cause more uncertainty

As part of their research the Inquiry conducted a survey of over 2,200 self-employed workers. Key findings included:

  • 46% said they were less likely to continue in self-employment due to their experience in the pandemic (18% unsure, 36% likely to continue)
  • 88% said the level of pandemic support for the self-employed was not a fair reflection of their tax contribution
  • 79% would oppose the equalisation of National Insurance Contributions between employees and the self-employed (21% support)
  • But 51% would support paying more out of their wages in exchange for a stronger safety net (12% oppose)
  • 75% do not believe they have sufficient workplace rights compared to employees (15% believe they do have sufficient rights)

Prospect general secretary Mike Clancy said:

“This pandemic has exposed the precarious nature of the UK’s self-employed workforce, with too many people risking too much to pursue their careers.

“It is time for a rebalancing of the risk and reward for the self-employed, with government acting to give greater support in the short term and a renewed sense of security and stability to protect against the uncertainty that the future holds.

“The self-employed can be the engine of our economic recovery if the government backs them now, this budget must be the one where the Chancellor finally delivers for our freelancers.”

Head of Bectu Philippa Childs said:

‘Workers in the creative industries have been left with little to no support from government schemes in the last year, resulting in a financial crisis for freelancers across the UK.

“There is a lack of understanding of how self-employment works in practise, which has led to schemes that don’t fit the reality of work life for many Bectu members.

“I urge the Chancellor to take on board the recommendations in this report, end the exclusion of millions of freelancers from government income support packages, and set out a new deal for freelancers and the self-employed for the future.”

Roy Rickhuss CBE, General Secretary of Community, said:

“Over the last year the self-employed have often been the forgotten millions of the pandemic when it comes to government support, leaving many of them left behind and facing significant financial hardship.

“Our report highlights the extent of the difficulties self-employed people have faced in the last twelve months. The government has thus far been unwilling to respond to these challenges, but what we need now is for them to act swiftly and implement our inquiry’s recommendations. In the immediacy the government must provide the self-employed of this country with financial support to address those excluded from existing schemes, so millions across the country no longer have to worry about paying their bills or putting food on the table. They must also act to provide greater security to the self-employed in the future, including by extending benefits like parental leave and sick pay as well as delaying the introduction of the IR35 regulations.

“Self-employed workers play a vital role in our national economy, making up roughly 15% of our workforce and being pivotal to the UK’s fastest growing and innovative industries such as in science, engineering, healthcare, the arts, entertainment, the media, and in the delivery of other important services across the country.  They must be supported through this pandemic and beyond. We hope the government heeds this report and creates a more stable foundation for self-employed workers in the future, and ensures that the many voices of currently struggling self-employed workers are heard.”

FSB National Vice-Chairman Martin McTague said:

“FSB was originally set up to be the voice for the self-employed in the 1970s, and we are now at a similarly critical moment for the UK’s self-employment community as we look to how to come out from this pandemic to 2030 and beyond.

The report includes a raft of proposals to help the self-employed stay in business and give them a shot at survival during these trying times.  It will be essential reading for the Treasury, to inform what we hope to see on 3 March – a Budget that drives recovery, clarifies support and regulation, and puts a thriving self-employed population back at the heart of its medium-to-long term economic plan.

“We’re grateful for the work Prospect is doing in this space and for including us in this important Commission’s work.”


Read the final report Download now

Take action

Ask your MP to put pressure on the Chancellor to support the self-employed in the Budget. We have written the letter for you – it only takes two minutes
Email your MP

Find out more

Discover more about the Inquiry into the Future of Self-Employment and read the report.
Find out more